Choosing Your Perfect Christmas Tree

Click on an image to enlarge!

Douglas Fir
Scotch Pine
Norway Spruce
Noble Fir
Fraser Fir
Grand Fir
Alpine Fir

You've arrived, with your kids and your camera, at your local tree farm in anticipation of finding, buying, and bringing home the perfect Christmas tree. You make your way into a field of beautiful evergreens, and all the trees seem like they'd look great in your family room. Which one should you choose? Well, that depends on what is most important to you…a tree that smells good, or a tree that won't drop its needles, or a tree that has a perfect "Christmas tree" shape. Because each variety has its own pros and cons, you can figure out beforehand which one best suits you and make your tree hunting a little easier!

The "classic" Christmas tree is the Douglas Fir. It has soft, medium-length needles. It has a nice, mellow scent, and good needle retention. Because it grows quickly, the Douglas Fir is usually reasonably priced, making it an excellent value and a great choice.


If you want a tree with excellent needle retention there are three good choices: the Noble Fir, the Alpine Fir, or the Fraser Fir. If you like to have your tree in your house the entire month of December and beyond, you would do well to choose one of these varieties. Their strong branches grow with space between each level of branches and the ones below it, providing you with wonderful ornament-hanging areas. These fir grow slowly and require hand pruning, making them more expensive trees to buy. But if you want a tree that will look just as good in 5 weeks as the day you bought it, you'll want to go ahead and spend the extra money!


The best smelling tree you can find is the Grand Fir. The Grand Fir is filled with a citrus-smelling sap, which makes the tree so fragrant. Crush one of the Grand's needles to release its wonderful aroma, and you'll have a preview of what your house will smell like when you bring this tree home. The downside? This tree does not have good needle retention, so if you want to have your tree up for several weeks, you may have to pass up the Grand Fir. But if you have your tree up for only a couple of weeks, and you want your house to smell like "Christmas," this is the tree for you!


A Spruce might be the ideal tree for you if you're looking for the perfectly shaped tree; the Spruce tree grows naturally in a cone shape with strong, upswept branches. Spruce needles are prickly, which can be a pro and a con. While you might have to wear leather gloves to decorate your tree, your cat will definitely leave it alone! The Spruce tree doesn't have good needle retention, so if you choose this tree, put it up as close to Christmas as possible.


The Pine tree has many good qualities: strong branches, good needle retention, and a pleasant aroma. This is another quick growing, reasonably priced tree. Pine needles are somewhat prickly though.
Remember that when you get your perfect tree home, regardless of the variety you've chosen, you need to cut at least ½ inch off the trunk immediately before you put it into water. This is true even if you've just cut the tree down 30 minutes before, because the sap that's in the tree's trunk immediately begins to seal the cut, making the tree unable to draw water. And give your tree plenty of water; a tree can draw up to four quarts of water a day!


Have fun choosing your tree, and have a very Merry Christmas!